The property
Reclassification % (of depreciable basis)
Typical study yields: residential 20-30% combined, commercial 25-40%. Remainder (75%) stays on 27.5-year SL.
Tax + study assumptions
NPV assumptions
Should you do the study?
Marginal — close callNPV is positive but not by a huge margin. Worth doing if you're in a high bracket; skippable on smaller deals or if you're between properties.
Year-1 tax savings boost
$32,914
vs straight-line baseline $10,764
Net NPV (after fee)
$30,480
Over 10 years @ 7.00% discount
Study fee payback
3 mo
Fee: $8,000
Year-1 deduction with cost seg
$118,047
Multiplier: 4.1×
Year-1 deduction without
$29,091
Plain straight-line baseline
Basis breakdown
| Purchase price | $1,000,000 |
| Less: land | −$200,000 |
| Depreciable basis | $800,000 |
| → 5-year | $80,000 |
| → 7-year | $40,000 |
| → 15-year | $80,000 |
| → Straight-line (27.5 yr) | $600,000 |
The recapture trade-off
Cost seg pulls depreciation FORWARD; it doesn't create new deductions. Every extra dollar deducted now becomes a dollar of §1250 / §1245 recapture at sale (25% federal). The NPV math above already accounts for this, but here's the cumulative number you'll owe on sale:
Recapture with cost seg
$100,545
On $402,182 cumulative depreciation
Recapture without
$72,727
On $290,909 cumulative depreciation
1031 exchange defers all of this. Roll into a replacement property at sale and the deferred gain (including recapture) carries over. Hold until death and heirs get a stepped-up basis — recapture vanishes.